From North Carolinians for Responsible Use of Sonar, www.ncrus.org
Environmental Impact Statement for USWTR
Three years ago, hundreds of you took action to help stop the Navy from building an ill-studied Undersea Warfare Training Range (USWTR) off the coast of North Carolina. Concerned citizens, fishermen, environmental organizations, and local officials identified serious flaws in the Navy's Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) - including its failure to properly analyze sonar's disastrous impacts on the marine environment or implement adequate mitigation measures. In response to overwhelming opposition to the EIS as presented, the Navy was forced to reassess its proposal to build a range for the intensive use of dangerous mid-frequency sonar over hundreds of square miles of ocean. Hearing your voices, the Navy withdrew its ill-conceived plan and promised to create a new Environmental Impact Statement that addressed concerns about impacts to fisheries, marine mammals, turtles, and hardbottom habitat.
On September 12, 2008, the Navy announced a new plan for its USWTR. But the only thing new about the plan is a change in its preferred location - this time off the northeast coast of Florida near Jacksonville and critical habitat for endangered Atlantic Right Whales. Again, the Navy's proposal fails to assess sonar's potential to cause significant harm to the marine environment. And the Navy repeats its failure to adopt common-sense protective measures it has used successfully in other places. And even though the preferred alternative for the Navy's USWTR has moved to Florida, the Navy could change course and again locate the USWTR off the coast of North Carolina.
Your voices must be heard again; we can ask the Navy to take another look at its plans, to better analyze the impacts of sonar and to protect the marine mammals, fish and sea turtles living off our shores. Speak out at one of the following hearings the Navy will hold on its USWTR proposal:
September 29, 2008
The Chincoteague Center
6155 Community Drive
The Navy's open house begins at 4:00 p.m. and the formal hearing begins at 7:00 p.m.
October 1, 2008
Crystal Coast Civic Center
3505 Arendell Street
Morehead City, NC
The Navy's open house begins at 6:00 p.m. and the formal hearing begins at 8:00 p.m.
October 6, 2008
The Sheraton North Charleston - Convention Center
4770 Goer Drive
North Charleston, SC
The Navy's open house begins at 5:00 p.m. and the formal hearing begins at 7:00 p.m.
October 7, 2008
The UNF University Center
12000 Alumni Drive
The Navy's open house begins at 5:00 p.m. and the formal hearing beings at 7:00 p.m.
The draft EIS can be read at http://projects.earthtech.com/USWTR/EIS/DOEIS_2008.htm.
2nd Environmental Impact Statement Concerning Sonar off North Carolina's Coast
On September 12, the Navy also released its draft Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for general sonar use and training in the Cherry Point Operating Area off North Carolina's coast. This draft EIS is available at http://www.navycherrypointrangecomplexeis.com/EIS.aspx. The Navy's documentation shows that even if USWTR is moved to the Florida coast, North Carolina will still bear much of the brunt of the Navy's sonar training, with many hundreds of hours of sonar use proposed for the Navy's operating areas in North Carolina's coastal waters. According to the Navy's own analysis, marine mammals would be significantly impacted by sonar as much as 400,000 times each year off North Carolina's coast. Nonetheless, the Navy refused to adopt mitigation measures that would help protect these and other marine animals.
In light of the Navy's failures and the real harm sonar poses to marine mammals and fish populations, please urge the Navy to withdraw its draft EIS and undertake a better analysis of sonar's impact on the marine environment and the people who depend on it.
Hearings on this draft EIS will be held in Beaufort, North Carolina on October 14 and in Wilmington, North Carolina on October 15. These public meetings begin at 5:00 p.m. with open houses and are concluded by formal hearings that begin at 7:00 p.m. The locations are:
North Carolina Maritime Museum
315 Front Street
Best Western Coastline Inn & Convention Center
503 Nutt Street
The Navy is asking that all comments on these draft EISs be sent to them by October 27, 2008. This time frame is unrealistic considering the complexity of the issues. The Navy and its dozen of consultants and contractors have taken years to produce these documents. The USWTR document is over 1,000 pages long and the North Carolina document is nearly 700 pages long, yet the Navy expects citizens to study these documents and submit comments within 45 days - the minimum time required by federal law.
What You Can Do
1. If you have not already done so, please go to www.ncrus.org and click on Contact Us to register for fast breaking news about what the Navy is doing.
2. Attend, and speak at if you will, one of the hearings discussed above.
3. Send the attached message to every elected official you can and to the Navy asking that the comment periods on these two EIS documents be delayed until January 15, 2009. The address for the Navy is:
Naval Facilities Engineering Command, Atlantic
Attention: Code EV22LL for USWTR and Code EV22SA for Cherry Point
6506 Hampton Boulevard
Norfolk, VA 23508-1278
The fax number for the USWTR document is (804) 200-5568. The fax number for the Cherry Point document is (757) 322-4894.
4. Stay alert for further guidance from NCRUS and our member / partner organizations about comment letters you might issue.
5. Forward this message to all your friends who care about ocean life and communities.
6. Send this message to the e-mail list that your organization maintains:
Sample Message Asking For an Extension of the Comment Periods until January 15
Re: Extra time needed for public comment on Navy's use of sonar
Dear [Navy, US Senator, US Representative, Governor, Local Official, Candidate for Office, etc.]:
I am writing to ask for your help in extending the comment periods on two important documents recently published by the U.S. Navy.
On September 12, 2008, the Navy released its latest draft environmental impact statement (EIS) for its planned development of an Undersea Warfare Training Range off the southeast coast of the United States. The Navy proposes to locate its training range just off of Jacksonville, Florida, near designated critical habitat for endangered Atlantic Right Whales. Repeating mistakes it made three years ago when it first analyzed the proposal for such a training range, the Navy failed to properly analyze the impacts of repeated use of mid-frequency sonar on marine creatures in the area. Nor did it propose to adequately mitigate the harmful effects of sonar. Despite the fact that the draft EIS is over 1,000 pages long, the Navy has limited the time in which the public/citizens may submit comments to a 45-day period. This is the very minimum time frame required by federal law/NEPA.
On the same day, the Navy released a draft EIS for sonar and other naval training exercises off the coast of North Carolina, in the Cherry Point Operating Area. The Navy's own analysis indicates that North Carolina marine mammals in this area will be significantly impacted hundreds of thousands of times by its use of sonar each year. Yet the Navy has refused to adopt mitigation measures that would help protect these animals, even though it has used mitigation measures in other parts of the world's oceans. Once again, although the draft EIS for the Cherry Point sonar training is nearly 700 pages long, the Navy limited its comment period to 45 days.
In light of the Navy's failure to adequately analyze the impacts of repeated use of sonar on marine creatures, the dense information provided by the Navy in justifying its plans, and the simultaneous issuance of related documents, I urge you to ask the Navy for an extension of the comment period until January 15, 2009. Such an extension will give citizens the time to thoroughly analyze the Navy's proposals and submit comments on these critical issues.
The New York Whale and Dolphin Action League
PO Box 273, Tuckahoe, NY 10707 USA
To subscribe send an email to email@example.com
A Project of Cetacean Society International
URL for this page: http://ny4whales.org/archive003.html